Classic Pulled Pork

We have a number of pulled pork recipes with different flavor profiles, but below is one of our standard versions.

This go to pulled pork, provides a sweet and spicy bite, that is not over powering and perfect with any type of soft roll.

The main trick to any good pulled pork is fire management. Keeping a consistent temp is key to super tender and delicious pork shoulder.

Ingredients:

  • 8 – 10 lb pork shoulder
  • 1 stick of butter
  • 1 cup Brown sugar
  • Seasoning mix: Smoked Paprika, course ground pepper, salt, garlic power, onion powder, celery seed, dry mustard. Mix to your personal taste. (Optional – chili powder, if you are looking for some heat)
  • Yellow mustard
  • 1 shaker Honey Hog, Meat Church (optional)

Instructions:

Prep:

  • Bring your smoker/ cooker up to 250 – 275 degrees.
  • Trim fat to an even level so the pork will smoke consistently.
  • Trim off any extra pieces of pork that is not completely attached.
  • Apply a light coating of mustard.
  • Liberally apply your seasoning mix.
  • Let sit for 15 – 30mins to allow the dry rub to penetrate the pork. The pork should look wet.

Phase 1:

  • Add the pork shoulder to the smoker/ cooker after the temp has stabilized between 250 – 275 degrees.
  • Spritz with apple juice during this phase.
  • Remove after internal temperature reaches around 165 – 175 degrees.

Phase 2:

  • Place pork shoulder into aluminum tray.
  • Spritz with apple juice.
  • (Optional) Coat with Honey Hog seasoning.
  • Place multiple slabs of butter on the top of the shoulder.
  • Add a cup/ handful of brown sugar on top of the butter.
  • Cover with aluminum foil.
  • Place back in smoker until the internal temperature reaches 205 degrees. If the pork is not probe tender, continue cooking until it is.

Rest:

  • Place the shoulder in a warming oven or cooler, covered with towels for at least 30 minutes or to hold for several hours, until ready to serve.
  • When ready – Pull the pork, removing any excess fat and bone.